Suggestions by @tracygjackson2011
1,297 suggestions
Carly Pope
as Natasha Wyatt in Black Christmas 2001
Amy Jo Johnson
as Jasmine Mosley in Black Christmas 2001
Paul Michael Robinson
as Thomas Kaufman in Black Christmas 2001
David Rees Snell
as Jonathon Conway in Black Christmas 2001
Lisa Marie Newmyer
as Sandra Myers in Black Christmas 2001
Rachel Blanchard
as Maggie Keller in Black Christmas 2001
Sarah Michelle Gellar
as Diana Webb in Black Christmas 2001
Brandon Flynn
as Derek Feldman in Scream 2
Sophie Anna Everhard
as Gina Lotnick in Urban Legends: Bloody Mary (2025)
Owen Teague
as Willy Owens in Urban Legends: Bloody Mary (2025)
Marteen
as Tom Higgins in Urban Legends: Bloody Mary (2025)
Elise Neal
as Grace Taylor in Urban Legends: Bloody Mary (2025)
Alisha Boe
as young Grace in Urban Legends: Bloody Mary (2025)
Joey Harris
as Samantha Owens in Urban Legends: Bloody Mary (2025)
Kathryn Newton
as Heather Thompson in Urban Legends: Bloody Mary (2025)
William Forsythe
as Ben Willis in I Know What You Did Last Summer (2007)
Rena Sofer
as Melissa "Missy" Egan in I Know What You Did Last Summer (2007)
Ben Feldman
as Barry Cox in I Know What You Did Last Summer (2007)
Bevin Prince
as Elsa Shivers in I Know What You Did Last Summer (2007)
Ashley Newbrough
as Julie James in I Know What You Did Last Summer (2007)