Suggestions by @timewarp

Heather (Total Drama)

as Choices in Characters Susie Elene should have played in the '80s

Score: +2

Aja Leith

as Choices in Characters Susie Elene should have played in the '80s

Score: +2

Tina Cohen-Chang

as Choices in Characters Susie Elene should have played in the '80s

Score: +2

Emma (Bodies Bodies Bodies)

as Choices in Characters Susie Elene should have played in the '80s

Score: +2

Gwen Wu

as Choices in Characters Susie Elene should have played in the '80s

Score: +2

Courtney Crimsen

as Choices in Characters Susie Elene should have played in the '80s

Score: +2

Sasha So

as Choices in Characters Susie Elene should have played in the '80s

Score: +2

Rumi (K-Pop Demon Hunters)

as Choices in Characters Susie Elene should have played in the '80s

Score: +2

Amber Tamblyn

as 2000s (Teen) in Sam Manson, From Decades Life Cycle

Score: +2

Fairuza Balk

as 90s (Teen) in Sam Manson, From Decades Life Cycle

Score: +2

Winona Ryder

as 80s (Teen) in Sam Manson, From Decades Life Cycle

Score: +2

Jenna Ortega

as 2020s (Teen) in Sam Manson, From Decades Life Cycle

Score: +2

Rosanna DeSoto

as Toñita Ramirez in Primos (80s Teen Cast)

Score: +2

Parveen Babi

as Serena in Primos (80s Teen Cast)

Score: +2

Freddie Prinze

as The Skid Malfeo in Primos (80s Teen Cast)

Score: +2

Domingo Ambriz

as Nachito Ramirez in Primos (80s Teen Cast)

Score: +2

Amy Irving

as Gordita Humphrey in Primos (80s Teen Cast)

Score: +2

Rachel Ticotin

as ChaCha Ramirez in Primos (80s Teen Cast)

Score: +2

Irene Cara

as Lucita Perez in Primos (80s Teen Cast)

Score: +2

Hilda Koronel

as LotLot Ramirez in Primos (80s Teen Cast)

Score: +2