Suggestions by @timemachine

Bianca Lawson

as Clawdeen Wolf in Monster High ('90s live-action movie)

Christina Ricci

as Draculaura in Monster High ('90s live-action movie)

Alicia Silverstone

as Frankie Stein in Monster High ('90s live-action movie)

Shaun Weiss

as Gibby in iCarly ('90s)

Kel Mitchell

as T-Bo in iCarly ('90s)

Matthew Lillard

as Spencer Shay in iCarly ('90s)

Matthew Lawrence

as Freddie Benson in iCarly ('90s)

Julia Stiles

as Sam Puckett in iCarly ('90s)

Natalie Portman

as Carly Shay in iCarly ('90s)

Margot Robbie

as Zoe in Fanboys (2019)

Rooney Mara

as Zoe in Fanboys (2014)

Nick Robinson

as Linus in Fanboys (2019)

Charlie McDermott

as Linus in Fanboys (2014)

Freddie Highmore

as Eric Bottler in Fanboys (2019)

Miles Teller

as Eric Bottler in Fanboys (2014)

Seth Rogen

as Harold Hutchinson in Fanboys (2019)

Jonah Hill

as Harold Hutchinson in Fanboys (2014)

Joe Keery

as Windows in Fanboys (2019)

Darren Criss

as Windows in Fanboys (2014)

Freddie Prinze Jr.

as Dan Humphrey in Gossip Girl ('90s)