Suggestions by @timemachine

Elisabeth Shue

as Larisa Oleynik in '90s Actors in the '80s

Jodie Foster

as Julia Stiles in '90s Actors in the '80s

Molly Ringwald

as Elisa Donovan in '90s Actors in the '80s

Heather Langenkamp

as Brittany Murphy in '90s Actors in the '80s

Robin Givens

as Stacey Dash in '90s Actors in the '80s

Heather Locklear

as Alicia Silverstone in '90s Actors in the '80s

Stefanie Powers

as Addison Montgomery in Grey's Anatomy (1985-2001)

Tony Danza

as Derek Shepherd in Grey's Anatomy (1985-2001)

Ernie Hudson

as Richard Webber in Grey's Anatomy (1985-2001)

Marla Gibbs

as Miranda Bailey in Grey's Anatomy (1985-2001)

Don Johnson

as Alex Karev in Grey's Anatomy (1985-2001)

Heather Locklear

as Izzie Stevens in Grey's Anatomy (1985-2001)

Lauren Tom

as Cristina Yang in Grey's Anatomy (1985-2001)

Linda Evans

as Meredith Grey in Grey's Anatomy (1985-2001)

Julia Louis-Dreyfus

as Principal Claire Swanson in Audio-Visual (1993-1997)

Jim Carrey

as Mr. Kenneth Middleton in Audio-Visual (1993-1997)

Bianca Lawson

as Anastacia Jenkins in Audio-Visual (1993-1997)

Lindsay Price

as Lillian Park in Audio-Visual (1993-1997)

Candace Cameron Bure

as Jennifer Herring in Audio-Visual (1993-1997)

Jonathan Brandis

as Oliver Randall in Audio-Visual (1993-1997)