Suggestions by @timemachine
8,262 suggestions
Theodore Borders
as Sam Carter in Goosebumps 2: Haunted Halloween (1998)
Jada Pinkett Smith
as Angela Bassett in American Horror Story (1990s)
Mario López
as Zach Villa in American Horror Story (1990s)
Jared Leto
as Cody Fern in American Horror Story (1990s)
Tori Spelling
as Emma Roberts in American Horror Story (1990s)
Alicia Silverstone
as Billie Lourd in American Horror Story (1990s)
Angela Bassett
as Angelica Ross in American Horror Story (1990s)
John Cusack
as Zachary Quinto in American Horror Story (1990s)
Susan Sarandon
as Jessica Lange in American Horror Story (1990s)
Pierce Brosnan
as Denis O'Hare in American Horror Story (1990s)
Brittany Murphy
as Taissa Farmiga in American Horror Story (1990s)
Leonardo DiCaprio
as Evan Peters in American Horror Story (1990s)
John Kassir
as Dylan McDermott in American Horror Story (1990s)
Heather Locklear
as Connie Britton in American Horror Story (1990s)
Ryan Phillippe
as Booker Strode in Freaky (2000)
Tobey Maguire
as Josh Detmer in Freaky (2000)
Matthew Lillard
as Booker Strode in Freaky (Late '90s)
Johnny Depp
as Booker Strode in Freaky (1990)
Will Friedle
as Josh Detmer in Freaky (Late '90s)
Leonardo DiCaprio
as Josh Detmer in Freaky (1995)