Suggestions by @timemachine

Olivia D'Abo

as '80s in Which Actress Should've Played Phantasma in Various Decades

P. J. Soles

as '70s in Which Actress Should've Played Phantasma in Various Decades

Twiggy

as '60s in Which Actress Should've Played Phantasma in Various Decades

Anthony Kramreither Jr.

as Conrad Fisher in The Summer I Turned Pretty ('80s)

Kelly Hu

as Isabel Conklin in The Summer I Turned Pretty ('80s)

Olivia D'Abo

as Phantasma in Scooby-Doo and the Ghoul School ('80s Live Action)

Heather O'Rourke

as Tanis in Scooby-Doo and the Ghoul School ('80s Live Action)

Winona Ryder

as Elsa Frankenteen in Scooby-Doo and the Ghoul School ('80s Live Action)

Keshia Knight Pulliam

as Winnie in Scooby-Doo and the Ghoul School ('80s Live Action)

Brooke Shields

as Sibella Dracula in Scooby-Doo and the Ghoul School ('80s Live Action)

Linda Purl

as 70's in Which Actress Should've Played Anna Banana in Different Decades?

Emma Kurtzman

as P.J. Soles in Which characters should actors have played in the 70’s?

Jessica Belkin

as 2020s in Which Actress Should've Played Emma Kurtzman in Various Decades

Madison Iseman

as 2010s in Which Actress Should've Played Emma Kurtzman in Various Decades

Maggie Grace

as 2000s in Which Actress Should've Played Emma Kurtzman in Various Decades

Larisa Oleynik

as '90s in Which Actress Should've Played Emma Kurtzman in Various Decades

Olivia D'Abo

as '80s in Which Actress Should've Played Emma Kurtzman in Various Decades

P. J. Soles

as '70s in Which Actress Should've Played Emma Kurtzman in Various Decades

Candice Bergen

as '60s in Which Actress Should've Played Emma Kurtzman in Various Decades

Alicia Witt

as Kimmy Mysner in Sym-Bionic Titan (90's Live Action)