Suggestions by @timemachine
8,262 suggestions
Heidi (13 Reasons Why)
as Choices in Characters Sian Barbara Allen should have played in the 1970s
Keanu Reeves
as Stewart Waldinger in Pepper Ann ('80s Live Action)
Kim Richards
as Brenda in Pepper Ann ('80s Live Action)
Lisa Bonet
as Vanessa James in Pepper Ann ('80s Live Action)
Lisa Bonet
as Tessa James in Pepper Ann ('80s Live Action)
Samantha Logan
as Effie Shrugg in Pepper Ann ('80s Live Action)
Renee Murphy
as Alice Kane in Pepper Ann ('80s Live Action)
Kelly Preston
as Cissy Rooney in Pepper Ann ('80s Live Action)
Elisabeth Shue
as Gwen Mezzrow in Pepper Ann ('80s Live Action)
Kate Vernon
as Trinket St. Clair in Pepper Ann ('80s Live Action)
Olivia D'Abo
as Nicky Little in Pepper Ann ('80s Live Action)
Lisa Pelikan
as Lydia Pearson in Pepper Ann ('80s Live Action)
Judith Barsi
as Margaret Pearson in Pepper Ann ('80s Live Action)
Molly Ringwald
as Pepper Ann Pearson in Pepper Ann ('80s Live Action)
Brad Carbunkle
as Alicia Witt in Which characters would you like to see actors play in the late 90s? (Genderswap)
Archie Andrews (Riverdale)
as Alicia Witt in Which characters would you like to see actors play in the late 90s? (Genderswap)
Jenna Ortega
as 2020s in Which Actress Should've Played Sophia Mendoza in Various Decades
Demi Lovato
as 2010s in Which Actress Should've Played Sophia Mendoza in Various Decades
America Ferrera
as 2000s in Which Actress Should've Played Sophia Mendoza in Various Decades
Jessica Alba
as '90s in Which Actress Should've Played Sophia Mendoza in Various Decades