Suggestions by @timemachine
8,262 suggestions
Girl in Cafeteria (She's All That)
as James Van Der Beek in Which Character Should Actors Have Played Genderswapped in the '90s
Keanu Reeves
as Mick in Idle Hands (1989)
Renee Murphy
as Tiffany in Idle Hands (1989)
Winona Ryder
as Tiffany in Idle Hands (1989)
Olivia D'Abo
as Tanya in Idle Hands (1989)
Dominick Brascia
as Pnub in Idle Hands (1989)
Lisa Bonet
as Debi LeCure in Idle Hands (1989)
Salma Hayek
as Molly in Idle Hands (1989)
Corey Haim
as Anton Tobias in Idle Hands (1989)
Dionne Warwick
as '60s in Which Actress Should've Played Audrey in Various Decades?
Taissa Turner
as Choices in Characters Rae Dawn Chong should have played in the 1980s
Dina (I Am Not Okay With This)
as Choices in Characters Rae Dawn Chong should have played in the 1980s
Maren Yearly
as Choices in Characters Rae Dawn Chong should have played in the 1980s
Abby Suso
as Choices in Characters Rae Dawn Chong should have played in the 1980s
Lavender LaViolette (Rainbow Rangers)
as Choices in Characters Rae Dawn Chong should have played in the 1980s
Ava Banji (Unicorn Academy)
as Choices in Characters Rae Dawn Chong should have played in the 1980s
Penny Lent
as Choices in Characters Rae Dawn Chong should have played in the 1980s
Stacy (Stranger Things)
as Choices in Characters Rae Dawn Chong should have played in the 1980s
Shelly Yuhan
as Choices in Characters Rae Dawn Chong should have played in the 1980s
Garnet
as Choices in Characters Rae Dawn Chong should have played in the 1980s