Suggestions by @themightylorog

Emmy Rossum

as Karen Roe in One Tree Hill

Score: +1

Bill Camp

as Coach Whitey Durham in One Tree Hill

Score: +1

Jules LeBlanc

as Brooke Davis in One Tree Hill

Score: 0

Tom Welling

as Dan Scott in One Tree Hill

Score: +1

Izabela Vidovic

as Haley James in One Tree Hill

Score: +1

Chloe Rose Robertson

as Peyton Sawyer in One Tree Hill

Score: +1

Brian Altemus

as Nathan Scott in One Tree Hill

Score: +1

Louis Partridge

as Lucas Scott in One Tree Hill

Score: +1

Manny Jacinto

as Timo in Mickey 17

Score: +2

Evan Rachel Wood

as Felicity Porter in Felicity (2008 - 2012)

Score: +4

Talia Ryder

as Mina Harker in Guillermo del Toro’s: Dracula (2026)

Score: +3

Peter Mensah

as General Vael-Korr in Superhuman (2002-2012)

Score: +1

Andrew Bryniarski

as D'Vorath in Superhuman (2002-2012)

Score: +1

Bernard Hill

as Garyn Sayce in Superhuman (2002-2012)

Score: +1

Rosa Salazar

as Princess Ioni Doyen in Superhuman (2002-2012)

Score: +1

Demián Bichir

as Emperor Calix Doyen in Superhuman (2002-2012)

Score: +1

Julian Sands

as Duko Vunis in Superhuman (2002-2012)

Score: +1

Joely Richardson

as The Angel in Superhuman (2002-2012)

Score: +1

Brian Tee

as Supernova in Superhuman (2002-2012)

Score: +1

Brenda Song

as Superhumanite in Superhuman (2002-2012)

Score: +1