Suggestions by @thefancaster

Mark Wahlberg

as John Blake in The Dark Knight Trilogy (1995-2002)

Score: +1

Russell Crowe

as Bane in The Dark Knight Trilogy (1995-2002)

Score: +1

Rachel Weisz

as Catwoman in The Dark Knight Trilogy (1995-2002)

Score: +1

Armand Assante

as Sal Maroni in The Dark Knight Trilogy (1995-2002)

Score: +1

Paul Sorvino

as Carmine Falcone in The Dark Knight Trilogy (1995-2002)

Score: +1

Kevin Spacey

as Two-Face in The Dark Knight Trilogy (1995-2002)

Score: +1

Willem Dafoe

as The Joker in The Dark Knight Trilogy (1995-2002)

Score: -1

Ray Winstone

as Arnold Flass in The Dark Knight Trilogy (1995-2002)

Score: +1

James Earl Jones

as Lucius Fox in The Dark Knight Trilogy (1995-2002)

Score: +1

Guy Pearce

as Scarecrow in The Dark Knight Trilogy (1995-2002)

Score: +1

Malcolm McDowell

as Henri Ducard in The Dark Knight Trilogy (1995-2002)

Score: +1

Malcom McDowell

as Henri Ducard in The Dark Knight Trilogy (1995-2002)

Score: -1

Ashley Judd

as Rachel Dawes in The Dark Knight Trilogy (1995-2002)

Score: +1

Harrison Ford

as Jim Gordon in The Dark Knight Trilogy (1995-2002)

Score: +1

Max von Sydow

as Alfred Pennyworth in The Dark Knight Trilogy (1995-2002)

Score: +1

Keanu Reeves

as Batman in The Dark Knight Trilogy (1995-2002)

Score: +1

Brandon Routh

as Superman in Batman: The Dark Knight Returns

Score: +2

John Cleese

as Alfred Pennyworth in Batman: The Dark Knight Returns

Score: 0

Kevin Spacey

as Two-Face in Batman: The Dark Knight Returns

Score: 0

Harrison Ford

as Jim Gordon in Batman: The Dark Knight Returns

Score: 0