Suggestions by @thecastmaker
1,761 suggestions

Mike Myers
as Toyman in Casting Every Superman Character

Brendan Gleeson
as Abner Cobblepot in Batman Returns (New Version)

Vanessa Williams
as Edna Jones in Batman Returns (New Version)

Orlando Jones
as Winston Jones in Batman Returns (New Version)

Emily Mortimer
as Martha Wayne in Batman Returns (New Version)

Justin Theroux
as Thomas Wayne in Batman Returns (New Version)

Blake Jenner
as Chip Schreck in Batman Returns (New Version)

Mark Acheson
as Lew Moxon in Batman Returns (New Version)

Tracey Walter
as Joe Chill in Batman Returns (New Version)

Sacha Baron Cohen
as Joker in Batman Returns (New Version)

Adewale Akinnuoye-Agbaje
as Killer Croc in Batman Returns (New Version)

Danny DeVito
as Red Triangle Circus’s former Ringleader in Batman Returns (New Version)

Cameron Britton
as Sal “Lucky” Maroni in Batman Returns (New Version)

KiKi Layne
as Gilda Grace-Dent in Batman Returns (New Version)

John David Washington
as D.A. Harvey Dent in Batman Returns (New Version)

David Harbour
as Commissioner James Gordon in Batman Returns (New Version)

Mark Rylance
as Alfred Pennyworth in Batman Returns (New Version)

Johnny Depp
as Max Schreck in Batman Returns (New Version)

Mia Goth
as Catwoman in Batman Returns (New Version)

Colin Farrell
as Penguin in Batman Returns (New Version)