Suggestions by @theaterfancasts

Chino Moreno

as Pontius Pilate in Jesus Christ Superstar

Score: +1

Alan Cumming

as King Herod in Jesus Christ Superstar

Score: +1

Jack Black

as King Herod in Jesus Christ Superstar

Score: +2

Adam Pascal

as Pontius Pilate in Jesus Christ Superstar

Score: +2

Norm Lewis

as Caiaphas in Jesus Christ Superstar

Score: +1

Drew Sarich

as Annas in Jesus Christ Superstar

Score: +1

Eleri Ward

as Mary Magdalene in Jesus Christ Superstar

Score: +1

Adam Lambert

as Judas in Jesus Christ Superstar

Score: +1

Adam Lambert

as Priest 3 in Jesus Christ Superstar

Score: -1

Josh Kiszka

as Jesus in Jesus Christ Superstar

Score: 0

Catherine Tate

as Mrs. Lovett in Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber of Fleet Street

Score: 0

Reeve Carney

as The Balladeer/Lee Harvey Oswald in Assassins

Score: +1

Jim Carrey

as Charles Guiteau in Assassins

Score: +1

Christian Borle

as Leon Cszolgosz in Assassins

Score: +1

Stephanie J. Block

as Sarah Jane Moore in Assassins

Score: +2

Erika Henningsen

as Lynette Fromme in Assassins

Score: +2

Paul Dano

as John Hinckley Jr. in Assassins

Score: +1

Catherine Tate

as Mrs Lovett in Sweeney Todd

Score: +1

Andrew Keenan-Bolger

as Giuseppe Zangara in Assassins

Score: +2

Ethan Slater

as The Balladeer/Lee Harvey Oswald in Assassins

Score: +1