Suggestions by @ the_only_kenesaw

Karen Gillan

as Captain Annabelle Cheddar in A Crown of Candy

Karen Gillan

as Annabelle Cheddar in A Crown of Candy

Madeline Madden

as Donna Troy/Troia in Perfect DCEU

+2-2Score: 0

Madeline Madden

as Donna Troy in Arrowverse

Ella Balinska

as Starfire in James Gunn's Justice League Quartology (2028-2040)

+3-2Score: +1

Allegra Acosta

as Jessica Cruz in James Gunn's Justice League Quartology (2028-2040)

Ariela Barer

as Jessica Cruz in James Gunn's Justice League Quartology (2028-2040)

Zachary Quinto

as Thaal Sinestro in James Gunn's Justice League Quartology (2028-2040)

+1-2Score: -1

Maitreyi Ramakrishnan

as Rachel Roth in James Gunn's Justice League Quartology (2028-2040)

Saara Chaudry

as Rachel Roth in James Gunn's Justice League Quartology (2028-2040)

+2-0Score: +2

Adam Nagaitis

as Leonard Snart in DCEU Rebooted

Madeline Madden

as Donna Troy in James Gunn's DC Universe

Madeline Madden

as Troy in Characters for future DC Movies

Madeline Madden

as Wonder Girl in DC CINEMATIC UNIVERSE REBOOTED

Madeline Madden

as Troia in DC Characters

Madeline Madden

as Donna Troy in DCEU Rebooted

Norman Reedus

as Atomic Skull in James Gunn’s Superman Villains

Aaron Paul

as Atomic Skull in James Gunn’s Superman Villains

Travis Fimmel

as Parasite in James Gunn’s Superman Villains