Suggestions by @thatcomicgurl

Charlie Cox

as Charles McNider in The Justice Society of America

Score: +1

Brec Bassinger

as Courtney Whitmore in The Justice Society of America

Score: +2

Alexander Ludwig

as Nine in Lorien Legacies Reborn

Score: +1

Alexander Ludwig

as Nine in Lorien Legacies

Score: -1

Tom Holland

as Sam Goode in Lorien Legacies

Score: +3

Felix Mallard

as Tyler Smallwood in The Vampire Diaries

Score: 0

Logan Shroyer

as Matt Honeycutt in The Vampire Diaries

Score: +9

Sophie Turner

as Caroline Forbes in The Vampire Diaries

Score: 0

Thomas Doherty

as Damon Salvatore in The Vampire Diaries

Score: +3

Anya Taylor-Joy

as Meredith Sulez in The Vampire Diaries

Score: -3

Luca Hollestelle

as Bonnie McCollough in The Vampire Diaries

Score: -3

Madison Iseman

as Katherine von Swartzschild in The Vampire Diaries

Score: +2

Madison Iseman

as Elena Gilbert in The Vampire Diaries

Score: +5

Lorenzo James Henrie

as Victor Mancha in Marvel's Runaways Season 4

Score: +3

Dove Cameron

as Melanie Jackson in Lorien Legacies Reborn

Score: +8

Zach Roerig

as The Vampire Diaries in Face Claims V5

Score: +1

Ian Somerhalder

as The Vampire Diaries in Face Claims V5

Score: 0

Paul Wesley

as The Vampire Diaries in Face Claims V5

Score: +3

Daniel Gillies

as The Vampire Diaries in Face Claims V5

Score: +1

Joseph Morgan

as The Vampire Diaries in Face Claims V5

Score: +1