Suggestions by @tfun2024

DJ Qualls

as Charlie the Prisoner in The Keepers of Darkness

Score: +1

Matt Berry

as Bill in The Keepers of Darkness

Score: +1

Steve Buscemi

as Kevin in The Keepers of Darkness

Score: +1

Steve Buscemi

as Kevin in The Makers Of Darkness

Score: +1

Ray McKinnon

as The Preacher in The Keepers of Darkness

Score: +1

Santiago Cabrera

as Briggs in The Makers Of Darkness

Score: +1

Kaley Cuoco

as Kara in The Makers Of Darkness

Score: +1

Patrick Kwok-Choon

as Charlie the Army Soldier in The Makers Of Darkness

Score: +1

Anson Mount

as Military Commander in Humvee in The Makers Of Darkness

Score: +1

Aldis Hodge

as Curt in The Makers Of Darkness

Score: +1

David Ajala

as Curt in The Makers Of Darkness

Score: +1

Anthony Proctor

as Narrator in The Makers Of Darkness

Score: +1

Wilson Cruz

as Radio Guy from Ohio in The Makers Of Darkness

Score: +1

Adam Sandler

as Radio Man from New Jersey in The Makers Of Darkness

Score: +1

Scott Grimes

as Scott in The Makers Of Darkness

Score: +1

Rong Fu

as Crystal in The Makers Of Darkness

Score: +1

J. Lee

as Lamonte in The Makers Of Darkness

Score: +1

Ronnie Rowe

as Lamonte in The Makers Of Darkness

Score: +1

Jess Bush

as Sarah in The Makers Of Darkness

Score: +1

Jacob Batalon

as Carl in The Makers Of Darkness

Score: +1