Suggestions by @tenshikichi

Aaron Tveit

as Captain America in The Avengers - The Musical

Zac Efron

as Hawkeye in The Avengers - The Musical

Tye Sheridan

as Tedros in The School for Good and Evil

Kiernan Shipka

as Agatha in The School for Good and Evil

Melissa Benoist

as Maggie Rogers in Mystery Incorporated

Doug Jones

as Mr. Carswell in Mystery Incorporated

Adam Goldberg

as Buck Masters in Mystery Incorporated

Josh Dallas

as Samuel Chastain Rogers in Mystery Incorporated

Becca Tobin

as Rachel Carswell in Mystery Incorporated

Rose Byrne

as Wendy Rogers in Mystery Incorporated

Ariela Barer

as Madelyn Dinkley in Mystery Incorporated

Libe Barer

as Velma Dinkley in Mystery Incorporated

Stephan James

as Wilfred Weathers in Mystery Incorporated

Cheyenne Jackson

as Jameson Hyde White in Mystery Incorporated

I. Marlene King

as Producer in Mystery Incorporated

Ross Butler

as Frederick Herman Jones in Mystery Incorporated

Annalise Basso

as Daphne Blake in Mystery Incorporated

Lana Parrilla

as Angie Dinkley in Mystery Incorporated

Roberto Aguirre-Sacasa

as Writer in Mystery Incorporated

Mark Ruffalo

as Dale Dinkley in Mystery Incorporated