Suggestions by @teeyutes
1,359 suggestions
Lee Marvin
as Joseph in We're No Angels (1975)
Sid Caesar
as Howard in The Treasure of the Sierra Madre (1988)
Eli Wallach
as Philip Stuckey in Pretty Woman (1950)

Ernest Borgnine
as Mick in Rocky (1986)
Fred MacMurray
as Edward Lewis in Pretty Woman (1950)

Henry Fonda
as Lt. Cmdr. Paul Cummings in The Americanization of Emily (1944)

Natalie Wood
as Princess Ann in Roman Holiday (1963)

Alan Ladd
as 1950s in What Actors Could've Played Rick Blaine in Various Decades?
Alan Ladd
as 1913 in Best Actor by Birthyear

Burt Lancaster
as 1913 in Best Actor by Birthyear

Jack Palance
as Long Jack in Captains Courageous (1957)

Alan Ladd
as Danny Velinski in The Great Escape (1953)

Walter Brennan
as Grandpa Joe in Willy Wonka & the Chocolate Factory (1961)
Daniel L. Fapp
as Cinematographer in Picnic (1965)

Andy Devine
as Major T. J. "King" Kong in Alfred Hitchcock's Dr. Strangelove
Steve McQueen
as Bruce Wayne in Batman (1969)

Neil Hamilton
as Jannes in The Ten Commandments (1966)
John Gielgud
as Sethi in The Ten Commandments (1966)
John Gielgud
as Blythe in The Great Escape (1953)
James Earl Jones
as King Mongkut of Siam in The King and I (1966)