Suggestions by @teeyutes
1,439 suggestions
Albert Finney
as Doyle Lonnegan in The Sting (1983)
Roberts Blossom
as Abraham Van Helsing in Dracula (1965)
James Whitmore
as Papa Elf in Elf (1993)
Walter Brennan
as Juror 9 in 12 Angry Men (1967)
Fredric March
as Howard Beale in Network (1956)
John Dehner
as Hatfield in Stagecoach (1949)
Ben Kingsley
as Flight Lieutenant Colin Blythe ('The Forger') in The Great Escape (1983)
Marie Windsor
as Dana Barrett in Ghostbusters (1950s)
Brad Dourif
as Ralph in In the Heat of the Night (1977)
Bela Lugosi
as Mr. Freeze in The Batman (1946)
Roberts Blossom
as Jim Casy in The Grapes of Wrath (1960)
Richard Hale
as 1940s in What Actors Could've Played The Green Goblin in Various Decades?
Karl Malden
as Tony in The Champ (1961)
Ernest Borgnine
as 1950's (Live-Action) in Which Actors Should’ve Played Mario in Various Decades?
Cedric Hardwicke
as Mr. Jordan in Here Comes Mr. Jordan (1941 recast)
Cesar Romero
as 1940's (Live-Action) in Which Actors Should’ve Played Luigi in Various Decades?
Edward Van Sloan
as Mr. Dawes, Jr. in Mary Poppins (1944)
Slim Pickens
as Marshal Link Appleyard in The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance (1972)
Liza Minnelli
as Page Conners in Heartbreakers (1971)
Aldo Ray
as Dean Cumanno in Heartbreakers (1971)