Suggestions by @teaserena

Mary Kate Wiles

as Emma Pillsbury in Glee (Recasting)

Kristen Bell

as Emma Pillsbury in Glee (Recasting)

Cecily Strong

as Cassandra July in Glee (Recasting)

Dacre Montgomery

as Dave Karofsky in Glee (Recasting)

John Mulaney

as Will Schuester in Glee (Recasting)

Milo Manheim

as Kurt Hummel in Glee (Recasting)

Joshua Bassett

as Blaine Anderson in Glee (Recasting)

Kate McKinnon

as Sue Sylvester in Glee (Recasting)

Jacob Elordi

as Finn Hudson in Glee (Recasting)

Joe Keery

as Finn Hudson in Glee (Recasting)

Amber Gray

as Calypso in The Odyssey

Timothée Chalamet

as Telemachus in The Odyssey

Sarah Paulson

as Penelope in The Odyssey

Oscar Isaac

as Poseidon in The Odyssey

Cody Fern

as Hermes in The Odyssey

Natalia Dyer

as Athena in The Odyssey

Naomi Scott

as Myra Khandaar in High School Story

Kaitlyn Dever

as Bethany Fox in High School Story

Diego Tinoco

as Julian Castillo in High School Story

Sydney Sweeney

as Emma Hawkins in High School Story