Suggestions by @taylerroberts

Chad Michael Murray

as Lucas Scott in One Tree Hill Reboot

Score: -1

Meg Donnelly

as Sawyer Scott in One Tree Hill Reboot

Score: 0

Bethany Joy Lenz

as Haley James Scott in One Tree Hill Reboot

Score: 0

Kiernan Shipka

as Mia Catalano in One Tree Hill Reboot

Score: 0

Selena Gomez

as Alex Dupre in One Tree Hill Reboot

Score: -1

Mädchen Amick

as Deb Scott in One Tree Hill Reboot

Score: +6

Marisol Nichols

as Karen Roe in One Tree Hill Reboot

Score: +1

Vivien Lyra Blair

as Lydia Scott in One Tree Hill Reboot

Score: +2

Trinity Likins

as Sawyer Scott in One Tree Hill Reboot

Score: +2

Lili Reinhart

as Sawyer Scott in One Tree Hill Reboot

Score: +2

Elijah Kelley

as Antwon Taylor in One Tree Hill Reboot

Score: +1

Channing Tatum

as Julian Baker in One Tree Hill Reboot

Score: +3

James Lafferty

as Nathan Scott in One Tree Hill Reboot

Score: +2

Meghann Fahy

as Haley James Scott in One Tree Hill Reboot

Score: -1

Trinity Likins

as Sawyer Brooke Scott in One Tree Hill Reboot

Score: +1

Rowan Blanchard

as Lilly Roe Scott in One Tree Hill Reboot

Score: +1

Jackson Brundage

as Jamie Scott in One Tree Hill Reboot

Score: +3

Hilarie Burton

as Peyton Sawyer Scott in One Tree Hill Reboot

Score: +5

Brendon Urie

as Jughead Jones in Riverdale (Adult Cast)

Score: -3

Candace Cameron Bure

as Betty Cooper in Riverdale (Adult Cast)

Score: -3