Suggestions by @tavitaylorde
312 suggestions
Sofia Coppola
as Carmen Loretta in ITAC 1996)
Chloë Sevigny
as Toni Kinney in ITAC 1996)
Jennifer Aniston
as Sara Ballion in ITAC 1996)
Chris Eigeman
as Gregg Murphy in ITAC 1996)
Gwyneth Paltrow
as Toni Kinney in ITAC 1996)
Leonardo DiCaprio
as Scott Case in ITAC 1996)
Lara Flynn Boyle
as Lennie McCarthy in ITAC 1996)
Courteney Cox
as Lennie McCarthy in ITAC 1996)
Gwen Stefani
as Maddie L in ITAC 1996)
Kirsten Dunst
as Céline Branigan in ITAC 1996)
Claire Danes
as Céline Branigan in ITAC 1996)
Liv Tyler
as Gina Banks in ITAC 1996)
Rosario Dawson
as Nicole Toledo in ITAC 1996)
Jason Priestley
as Scott Case in ITAC 1996)
Josh Hartnett
as Deven Shaw in ITAC 1996)
Pico Alexander
as Paul Campbell in In the Angel's City (ruled by popular demand)
Dacre Montgomery
as Chip Astin in Illicit Affairs
Fred Hechinger
as Chip Astin in Illicit Affairs
Tahar Rahim
as Davis Dyer in Illicit Affairs
Christopher Abbott
as Davis Dyer in Illicit Affairs