Suggestions by @tabbycat22

Luke Massy

as Sheriff Alan Cunningham in Kindred: Recrudescence 2

Score: +1

Luke Massy

as Sheriff Alan Cunningham in Friday the 13th: Recrudescence

Score: +1

Brennan Bailey

as Deputy Dan Pierce in Friday the 13th: Recrudescence

Score: +1

Vincente DiSanti

as Jason Voorhees in Friday the 13th: Recrudescence

Score: +1

Kane Hodder

as Jason Voorhees in Friday the 13th: Recrudescence

Score: +2

Derek Mears

as Jason Voorhees in Friday the 13th: Recrudescence

Score: +2

William Miller

as Deputy Matthew Rosenthal in Halloween: Evil Never Dies

Score: +1

Sophia Pettit

as Melody Loomis in Halloween: Evil Never Dies

Score: +1

Elias Harger

as Steven (Lloyd) Clark in Halloween: Evil Never Dies

Score: +1

Jack Fisher

as Steven (Lloyd) Clark in Halloween: Evil Never Dies

Score: +1

Annie "Bee" Smith

as Rachel (Lloyd) Clark in Halloween: Evil Never Dies

Score: +2

Mary Hasani

as Rachel (Lloyd) Clark in Halloween: Evil Never Dies

Score: +1

Susie Amy

as Amelia Loomis in Halloween: Evil Never Dies

Score: +1

Danielle Harris

as Jamie Lloyd in Halloween: Evil Never Dies

Score: +4

Vincente DiSanti

as Michael Myers in Halloween: Evil Never Dies

Score: +1

James Jude Courtney

as Michael Myers in Halloween: Evil Never Dies

Score: +1

Paul T. Taylor

as Pinhead in Hellraiser

Score: +1

Matt Doran

as Ryan Nelson in Halloween: The Shadow of Michael Myers

Score: +1

Nicholas Hastings

as Garrett Davis in Halloween: The Shadow of Michael Myers

Score: +1