Suggestions by @swk1690

Winona Ryder

as Alicia Masters in Chris Columbus' Fantastic Four (2005)

Tobey Maguire

as Spider Man in Chris Columbus' Fantastic Four (2005)

Richard Dean Anderson

as Peter Petruski in Chris Columbus' Fantastic Four (2005)

Dash Mihok

as Peter Petruski in Chris Columbus' Fantastic Four (2005)

Howard Ashman

as Peter Petruski in Chris Columbus' Fantastic Four (2005)

Dash Mihok

as Peter Petruski in Chris Columbus' Fantastic Four (2005)

Ty Olsson

as Flint Marko in Chris Columbus' Fantastic Four (2005)

Nana Visitor

as Alicia Masters in Chris Columbus' Fantastic Four (2005)

Richard Dean Anderson

as Peter Petruski in Chris Columbus' Fantastic Four (2005)

Emily Watson

as Alicia Masters in Chris Columbus' Fantastic Four (2005)

Ralph Fiennes

as Annihilus in Chris Columbus' Fantastic Four (2005)

Sam Hamm

as Writer in Chris Columbus' Fantastic Four (2005)

Christina Ricci

as Rogue in X2

Ethan Hawke

as Scott Summer in X2

Sarah Michelle Gellar

as Rogue in X2

Sarah Michelle Gellar

as Marie in X-men: The Last Stand

Daniel Day-Lewis

as Bentley Wittman in Chris Columbus' Fantastic Four (2005)

Viggo Mortensen

as Bentley Wittman in Chris Columbus' Fantastic Four (2005)

Thomas Haden Church

as Flint Marko in Chris Columbus' Fantastic Four (2005)

Charlize Theron

as Susan Storm in Peyton Reed's Fantastic Four (2005)