Suggestions by @swk1690

Winona Ryder

as Alicia Masters in Chris Columbus' Fantastic Four (2005)

Score: +1

Tobey Maguire

as Spider Man in Chris Columbus' Fantastic Four (2005)

Score: +1

Richard Dean Anderson

as Peter Petruski in Chris Columbus' Fantastic Four (2005)

Score: +1

Dash Mihok

as Peter Petruski in Chris Columbus' Fantastic Four (2005)

Score: +1

Howard Ashman

as Peter Petruski in Chris Columbus' Fantastic Four (2005)

Score: +1

Dash Mihok

as Peter Petruski in Chris Columbus' Fantastic Four (2005)

Score: +1

Ty Olsson

as Flint Marko in Chris Columbus' Fantastic Four (2005)

Score: +1

Nana Visitor

as Alicia Masters in Chris Columbus' Fantastic Four (2005)

Score: +1

Richard Dean Anderson

as Peter Petruski in Chris Columbus' Fantastic Four (2005)

Score: +1

Emily Watson

as Alicia Masters in Chris Columbus' Fantastic Four (2005)

Score: +1

Ralph Fiennes

as Annihilus in Chris Columbus' Fantastic Four (2005)

Score: +1

Sam Hamm

as Writer in Chris Columbus' Fantastic Four (2005)

Score: +1

Christina Ricci

as Rogue in X2

Score: 0

Ethan Hawke

as Scott Summer in X2

Score: -2

Sarah Michelle Gellar

as Rogue in X2

Score: 0

Sarah Michelle Gellar

as Marie in X-men: The Last Stand

Score: 0

Daniel Day-Lewis

as Bentley Wittman in Chris Columbus' Fantastic Four (2005)

Score: +1

Viggo Mortensen

as Bentley Wittman in Chris Columbus' Fantastic Four (2005)

Score: +1

Thomas Haden Church

as Flint Marko in Chris Columbus' Fantastic Four (2005)

Score: +1

Charlize Theron

as Susan Storm in Peyton Reed's Fantastic Four (2005)

Score: +4