Suggestions by @stracciatella

Maddie Ziegler

as Laura Lizzie in The Craft

Score: +2

Bailee Madison

as Laura Lizzie in The Craft

Score: +1

Nicholas Hamilton

as Chris Hooker in The Craft

Score: +1

Neve Campbell

as Chloe Bailey in The Craft

Score: +1

Robin Tunney

as Chloe Bailey in The Craft

Score: +3

Skai Jackson

as Rochelle Whitman in The Craft

Score: +3

Marsai Martin

as Rochelle Whitman in The Craft

Score: +5

Ariel Winter

as Bonnie Harper in The Craft

Score: +1

Mackenzie Foy

as Sarah Bailey in The Craft

Score: +1

Rowan Blanchard

as Sarah Bailey in The Craft

Score: +2

Jodelle Ferland

as Nancy Downs in The Craft

Score: -2

Sophia Lillis

as Nancy Downs in The Craft

Score: +3

Scott Eastwood

as Chris Redfield in Resident Evil Universe

Score: 0

Ari Aster

as Director in Witchcraft

Score: +1