Suggestions by @stevehardpark

Helena Bonham Carter

as Sister Creep in Swan Song

Score: +4

Laura Dern

as Sister Creep in Swan Song

Score: +3

Zendaya

as Sue Wanda Prescott in Swan Song

Score: -4

Andre Royo

as Rusty in Swan Song

Score: +1

Crispin Glover

as Friend in Swan Song

Score: +5

John Lithgow

as PawPaw in Swan Song

Score: +2

Ben Mendelsohn

as Friend in Swan Song

Score: +1

Willem Dafoe

as Colonel Macklin in Swan Song

Score: +5

Chad L. Coleman

as Josh Hutchins in Swan Song

Score: +5

Corey Parker Robinson

as Josh Hutchins in Swan Song

Score: -1