Suggestions by @steelsheik

Alexander Skarsgård

as Solomon Mikaelson in The Vampire Diaries

Larenz Tate

as Robert Maxwell in The Vampire Diaries

Jensen Ackles

as Thomas Gilbert in The Vampire Diaries

Sarah Gadon

as Elizabeth Morrow-Gilbert in The Vampire Diaries

Kit Harington

as Baron von Swartzschild in The Vampire Diaries

Steve Schirripa

as Conti Di Giuseppe Salvatore in The Vampire Diaries

Kerry Washington

as Gudren in The Vampire Diaries

Mackenyu

as Shinichi in The Vampire Diaries

Lyrica Okano

as Misao in The Vampire Diaries

Jaylen Barron

as Lady Ulma in The Vampire Diaries

Matthew Daddario

as Damon Salvatore in The Vampire Diaries

Elisha Cuthbert

as Judith Gilbert-Maxwell in The Vampire Diaries

Timothée Chalamet

as Ethan Crane in The Vampire Diaries

Lily-Rose Depp

as Jessalyn D'Aubigne in The Vampire Diaries

Noah Centineo

as Sage in The Vampire Diaries

Nicole Muñoz

as Vickie Bennett in The Vampire Diaries

Nick Robinson

as Caleb Smallwood in The Vampire Diaries

Ellarose Kaylor

as Brianna Smallwood in The Vampire Diaries

Jett Klyne

as Lucas Smallwood in The Vampire Diaries

Dylan O'Brien

as Tyler Smallwood in The Vampire Diaries