Suggestions by @stardog

Josh Holloway

as Alexander Woodroe in All the Feels

Score: +1

Ben Barnes

as Marcus Caster-Rupp in Spoiler Alert

Score: -2

Chris Pine

as Alexander Woodroe in All the Feels

Score: +1

Anthony Hopkins

as Keir in ACOTAR

Score: -2

Royce Pierreson

as Tarquin in ACOTAR

Score: +3

Jared Leto

as Eris in ACOTAR

Score: -4

Eva Green

as Amarantha in ACOTAR

Score: +8

Claire Holt

as Morrigan in ACOTAR

Score: +4

Luke Pasqualino

as Azriel in ACOTAR

Score: +1

Tom Ellis

as Rhysand in ACOTAR

Score: -4

Michele Morrone

as Rhysand in ACOTAR

Score: 0

Melissa McCarthy

as Lauren Clegg in All the Feels

Score: +1

Chris Hemsworth

as Alexander Woodroe in All the Feels

Score: +3

Francisco San Martin

as Marcus Caster-Rupp in Spoiler Alert

Score: -1

Tess Holliday

as April Whittier in Spoiler Alert

Score: 0