Suggestions by @spetmother
20 suggestions
Grant Gustin
as The Thief in The Kidnapping of Sam Evans
Spoiler
as The Thief in The Kidnapping of Sam Evans
Jane Lynch
as Sue Sylvester in The Kidnapping of Sam Evans
Dot-Marie Jones
as Coach Beistie in The Kidnapping of Sam Evans
Jayma Mays
as Emma Pillsburry in The Kidnapping of Sam Evans
Matthew Morrison
as Will Schuester in The Kidnapping of Sam Evans
Vanessa Lengies
as Sugar Motta in The Kidnapping of Sam Evans
Chris Colfer
as Kurt Hummel in The Kidnapping of Sam Evans
Mark Salling
as Noah Puckerman in The Kidnapping of Sam Evans
Amber Riley
as Mercedes Jones in The Kidnapping of Sam Evans
Jenna Ushkowitz
as Tina Cohen-Chang in The Kidnapping of Sam Evans
Harry Shum Jr.
as Mike Chang in The Kidnapping of Sam Evans
Heather Morris
as Brittany S. Pierce in The Kidnapping of Sam Evans
Naya Rivera
as Santana Lopez in The Kidnapping of Sam Evans
Dianna Agron
as Quinn Fabray in The Kidnapping of Sam Evans
Damian McGinty
as Rory Flanagan in The Kidnapping of Sam Evans
Cory Monteith
as Finn Hudson in The Kidnapping of Sam Evans
Lea Michele
as Rachel Berry in The Kidnapping of Sam Evans
Darren Criss
as Blaine Anderson in The Kidnapping of Sam Evans
Chord Overstreet
as Sam Evans in The Kidnapping of Sam Evans