Suggestions by @spectral_kelpie

Judi Dench

as Anastasia Luccio (Older) in The Dresden Files

Score: -2

Nick Frost

as Mr. Bumble in Oliver! (remake)

Score: +1

Ryan Alessi

as The Artful Dodger in Oliver! (remake)

Score: 0

Stephen Moyer

as Gil Favor in Rawhide Reboot

Score: +1

Karl Urban

as Clay Forrester in Rawhide Reboot

Score: +1

Tom Felton

as Josef Kostan in Moonlight Reboot

Score: +1

Colin Morgan

as Josef Kostan in Moonlight Reboot

Score: +2

Jesse Eisenberg

as Josef Kostan in Moonlight Reboot

Score: +1

Samantha Barks

as Coraline Duvall in Moonlight Reboot

Score: +1

Emmy Rossum

as Coraline Duvall in Moonlight Reboot

Score: +1

Roberto Cavazos

as Guillermo Gasol in Moonlight Reboot

Score: +1

Henry Frost

as Josh Linsey in Moonlight Reboot

Score: +1

Ben Presley

as Josh Linsey in Moonlight Reboot

Score: +1

Jeff Pierre

as Carl Davis in Moonlight Reboot

Score: +1

Trevante Rhodes

as Carl Davis in Moonlight Reboot

Score: +1

Laya Lewis

as Maureen Williams in Moonlight Reboot

Score: +2

Gal Gadot

as Maureen Williams in Moonlight Reboot

Score: +1

Madison Iseman

as Beth Turner in Moonlight Reboot

Score: +1

Luke Thompson

as Mick St. John in Moonlight Reboot

Score: +3

David Henrie

as Mick St. John in Moonlight Reboot

Score: +1