Suggestions by @spanoulishgc

Keith Carradine

as Sam Lane in Superman 3 (2007)

Score: +1

Jenna Fischer

as Lana Lang in Superman 3 (2007)

Score: +1

Rebecca Wisocky

as Lana Lang in Superman 3 (2007)

Score: -2

Brandon Routh

as Bizarro in Superman 3 (2007)

Score: +1

Dylan McDermott

as Metallo in Superman 3 (2007)

Score: +1

Tom Hollander

as Metallo in Superman 3 (2007)

Score: -1

Daniel Day-Lewis

as Lex Luthor (Visiones) in Superman 3 (2007)

Score: +1

Joely Richardson

as Cat Grant in Superman 3 (2007)

Score: +1

Simon Pegg

as Jimmy Olsen in Superman 3 (2007)

Score: +1

Josh Holloway

as Dr. Alexander Sartorius in Superman 3 (2007)

Score: +1

Tommy Lee Jones

as Perry White in Superman 3 (2007)

Score: +1

Vanessa Redgrave

as Martha Kent in Superman 3 (2007)

Score: +1

Erik King

as Steel in Superman 3 (2007)

Score: +2

Carrie-Anne Moss

as Lois Lane in Superman 3 (2007)

Score: +1

Brendan Fraser

as Superman in Superman 3 (2007)

Score: +1

Sam Raimi

as Director in Superman 3 (2007)

Score: +1

Joel Silver

as Producer in Superman 3 (2007)

Score: +1

Josh Holloway

as Dr. Alexander Sartorius in Superman 2 (2004)

Score: +1

Julie Dreyfus

as Mercy Graves in Superman 2 (2004)

Score: +1

Desmond Harrington

as TJ White in Superman 2 (2004)

Score: +1