Suggestions by @sonictiger

Sarah Snook

as The Killer in We Must Be Killers

Kyle Dixon & Michael Stein

as Composer in We Must Be Killers

Leigh Janiak

as Producer in We Must Be Killers

The Duffer Brothers

as Director in We Must Be Killers

sonictiger

as Writer in We Must Be Killers

Noah Schnapp

as The Killer's Accomplice in We Must Be Killers

Spoiler

as The Killer's Accomplice in We Must Be Killers

Spoiler

as The Killer in We Must Be Killers

Jason Schwartzman

as Dr. Cox in We Must Be Killers

Sasha Calle

as Vera Jones in We Must Be Killers

John David Washington

as Tyler Hammond in We Must Be Killers

Ryan Potter

as Isaiah Hudson in We Must Be Killers

Peyton Elizabeth Lee

as Kristen "Kristy" Cain in We Must Be Killers

Millie Bobby Brown

as Angela Hamilton in We Must Be Killers

Noah Schnapp

as Justin Hamilton in We Must Be Killers

Rachel Zegler

as Jennifer Roberts in We Must Be Killers

Finn Wolfhard

as Xavier Walker in We Must Be Killers

Maxwell Jenkins

as Jace Robinson in We Must Be Killers

Jenna Ortega

as Nadia Jones in We Must Be Killers

Tom Holkenborg

as Composer in The Defenders: A Star-Spangled Team-Up