Suggestions by @slugslime

Natalie Portman

as Sebille in Divinity: Original Sin 2

Score: -2

Hillary Clinton

as Dallis the Hammer in Divinity: Original Sin 2

Score: -1

Amanda Seyfried

as Lohse in Divinity: Original Sin 2

Score: -5

Kirsten Dunst

as Dallis the Hammer in Divinity: Original Sin 2

Score: +1

Jason Momoa

as Gareth in Divinity: Original Sin 2

Score: -1

Eva Green

as Sebille in Divinity: Original Sin 2

Score: 0

Keanu Reeves

as Ifan Ben-Mezd in Divinity: Original Sin 2

Score: -3

Oscar Isaac

as Ifan Ben-Mezd in Divinity: Original Sin 2

Score: -1

Riz Ahmed

as Ifan Ben-Mezd in Divinity: Original Sin 2

Score: -2

Rahul Kohli

as Ifan Ben-Mezd in Divinity: Original Sin 2

Score: 0

Meryl Streep

as Windego in Divinity: Original Sin 2

Score: -1

Kaitlin Bennett

as Dallis the Hammer in Divinity: Original Sin 2

Score: -4

Aubrey Plaza

as Malady in Divinity: Original Sin 2

Score: -2

Eric Trump

as Bishop Alexandar in Divinity: Original Sin 2

Score: -1

Mark Zuckerberg

as Bishop Alexandar in Divinity: Original Sin 2

Score: -3

Elon Musk

as Bishop Alexandar in Divinity: Original Sin 2

Score: -4

Kirsten Vangsness

as Portia Devorak in The Arcana

Score: -2

Peter Steele

as Muriel in The Arcana

Score: 0