Suggestions by @sleepyghost

Matthew Lillard

as Dr. Enon. in Sally Face

Score: 0

Alex Zahara

as Dr. Enon. in Sally Face

Score: +2

Shailene Woodley

as Ashley Campbell in Sally Face

Score: 0

Winona Ryder

as Lisa Johnson in Sally Face

Score: +2

Eric André

as Gizmo Voice in Sally Face

Score: +1

Mark Fischbach

as Gizmo Voice in Sally Face

Score: +1

Sean "JackSepticeye" McLoughlin

as Gizmo Voice in Sally Face

Score: +4

Diane Keaton

as Mrs. Packerton in Sally Face

Score: +1

Cara Horgan

as Lisa Johnson in Sally Face

Score: +1

Sandra James-Young

as Mrs. Gibson in Sally Face

Score: +1

Arthur Darvill

as Herman Sanderson in Sally Face

Score: +5

Aaron Paul

as CJ in Sally Face

Score: +1

Federico Cesari

as CJ in Sally Face

Score: +2

Lily James

as Stacey Holmes in Sally Face

Score: +1

Presley Smith

as Megan Holmes in Sally Face

Score: +3

Charlie Talbert

as Jim Johnson in Sally Face

Score: +1

Ariela Barer

as Maple Cohen in Sally Face

Score: +1

Forrest Goodluck

as Travis Phelps in Sally Face

Score: +1

Niamh Walsh

as Diane Fisher in Sally Face

Score: +1

Danny Kirrane

as Charley Mansfield in Sally Face

Score: 0