Suggestions by @slamadams

Mahershala Ali

as Eric Brooks in Bloodstone (Netflix)

Ricky Whittle

as Eric Brooks in Bloodstone (Netflix)

Charles Dance

as Mephisto in Midnight Sons

Marc Warren

as John Constantine in Constantine

Brianna Hildebrand

as Cassie Hack in Hack/Slash

Danny Pudi

as Morty in Nailbiter

Kathryn Hahn

as Abigail Barker in Nailbiter

Brad Beyer

as Louis Fairgold in Nailbiter

Yvonne Strahovski

as Joy Lauren in Nailbiter

Kaitlyn Dever

as Alice Crane in Nailbiter

Clancy Brown

as Raleigh Woods in Nailbiter

Bruce Campbell

as Raleigh Woods in Nailbiter

John Carroll Lynch

as Raleigh Woods in Nailbiter

Tyler Labine

as Elliot Carroll in Nailbiter

Jaime Pressly

as Shannon Crane in Nailbiter

Kevin Hanchard

as Nicolas Finch in Nailbiter

Seann William Scott

as Edward Charles Warren in Nailbiter

Jonah Hill

as Jake in Murder Falcon

Jack Black

as Murder Falcon in Murder Falcon

Aubrey Plaza

as Black Widow (Ultimate) in The Spider-Verse Spinoffs