Suggestions by @simon23

Nicholas D'Agosto

as Connor in Detroit Become Human Recasting/Fancasting

Score: -6

Thomas Jane

as Rick Grimes in The Walking Dead

Score: +1

Sebastian Stan

as Nate in Fallout 4

Score: +4

Johnny Depp

as Nate in Fallout 4

Score: -5

Pedro Pascal

as Joel2 in The Last of Us Part 1 & 2

Score: +1

Pedro Pascal

as Joel in The Last of Us Part 1 & 2

Score: +3

Bella Ramsey

as Ellie in The Last of Us Part 1 & 2

Score: +1

Oscar Isaac

as Danse in Fallout 4

Score: 0

Charlie Heaton

as Macready in Fallout 4

Score: 0

John David Washington

as X6-88 in Fallout 4

Score: +2

Richard Madden

as Elder Maxson in Fallout 4

Score: +1

Walton Goggins

as Trevor Phillips in Video Games Characters Fancast

Score: +1

Til Schweiger

as B.J. Blazkowicz in Video Games Characters Fancast

Score: +4

Anne Hathaway

as Nora in Fallout 4

Score: +1

Marion Cotillard

as Curie in Fallout 4

Score: +1

Jennifer Connelly

as Nora in Fallout 4

Score: +1

Keira Knightley

as Nora in Fallout 4

Score: +1

Michael Rooker

as Hancock in Fallout 4

Score: +1

Jessica Chastain

as Desdemona in Fallout 4

Score: +1

Bob Odenkirk

as Vault-Tec Rep in Fallout 4

Score: +1