Suggestions by @silmarils
435 suggestions
Ian McKellen
as Gandalf in The Silmarillion
Benedict Cumberbatch
as Sauron in The Silmarillion
Cate Blanchett
as Galadriel in The Silmarillion
Peter Jackson
as Director in The Silmarillion
Liv Tyler
as The Judge in Till We Have Faces
Liam Hemsworth
as The God of the Mountain in Till We Have Faces
Hailee Steinfeld
as Psyche in Till We Have Faces
Sean Connery
as The Fox in Till We Have Faces
Jeremy Irons
as King of Glome in Till We Have Faces
Anna Popplewell
as Redival in Till We Have Faces
Emilia Clarke
as Orual in Till We Have Faces
Betty White
as The Patient's Mother in The Screwtape Letters
Hugh Jackman
as Fr. Spike in The Screwtape Letters
Kristen Stewart
as The Patient's Love Interest in The Screwtape Letters
Robert Pattinson
as Wormwood in The Screwtape Letters
Joseph Mazzello
as The Patient in The Screwtape Letters
Ralph Fiennes
as Screwtape in The Screwtape Letters
Ralph Winter
as Producer in The Screwtape Letters
Parminder Nagra
as Tinidril in The Space Trilogy
Cate Blanchett
as Perelandra in The Space Trilogy