Suggestions by @sienakelly

Sadie Sink

as Circe in Circe

Score: -7

Chloë Grace Moretz

as Ruby Thompson in Some Girls Do

Score: +2

Hayley Williams

as Libby in The Inheritance Games

Score: -30

Simon Rex

as Drake Sanders in The Inheritance Games

Score: -3

Lisseth Chavez

as Alisa Ortega in The Inheritance Games

Score: -18

Rahul Kohli

as Scarecrow in Harley Quinn DC Universe Animated Series (Live Action)

Score: +4

Eliza Scanlen

as Celia St. James in The Seven Husbands of Evelyn Hugo

Score: -28

Hunter Schafer

as Zee in The Disasters

Score: +1

Cate Blanchett

as Lillian Pentecost in Fortune Favors the Dead

Score: +1

Allison Ponthier

as Willowjean Parker in Fortune Favors the Dead

Score: +2

Natalia Tena

as Fiona Pitch in Carry On

Score: +2

Shannon Berry

as Niamh Brody in Carry On

Score: +6

Thomas Doherty

as Smith Smith-Richards in Carry On

Score: +1

Anna Lore

as Pippa in Carry On

Score: +4

Margot Robbie

as Harley Quinn in James Gunn's Harley Quinn

Score: +4

Henry Cavill

as Superman/Bizarro in The Suicide Squad: Danger Zone

Score: +2

Andy Samberg

as Kite Man in The Suicide Squad: Danger Zone

Score: +1

Jack Haven

as Alex Fierro in Magnus Chase

Score: +3

Margot Robbie

as The Most Comic-Accurate Castings in Best & Worst Comic Book Castings

Score: +15

Margot Robbie

as Best Costumes in Best & Worst Comic Book Castings

Score: +25