Suggestions by @sickfixx

Wentworth Miller

as Charles Xavier in Marvel Cinematic Universe

Score: -1

Stephen McHattie

as Mephisto in Marvel Cinematic Universe

Score: +2

tomandandy

as Composer in Batman: Knightshift

Score: +1

Richard Kelly

as Director in Batman: Knightshift

Score: +1

Tim Roth

as Mathiu Silverburg in SUIKODEN

Score: +1

Michael Horse

as Captain Bartholomew in Wild Arms

Score: +1

Joe Seanoa

as Belselk in Wild Arms

Score: +1

Alexander Ludwig

as Flash Boomerang in Wild Arms

Score: +1

Seth Rollins

as Zed in Wild Arms

Score: +1

Rebecca Quin

as Lady Harken in Wild Arms

Score: +1

Saxon Sharbino

as Princess Cecilia Adlehyde in Wild Arms

Score: +1

Taylor Kitsch

as Jack Van Burace in Wild Arms

Score: +1

Andy Serkis

as Alzahad in Wild Arms

Score: +1

Jack Quaid

as Rudy Roughnight in Wild Arms

Score: +1

Grace Zabriskie

as Mother in Wild Arms

Score: +1

Liev Schreiber

as Zeikfried in Wild Arms

Score: +1

Sara Paxton

as Gamora in Warlock and the Infinity Watch (2020)

Score: +1

Phil Fondacaro

as Pip the Troll in Warlock and the Infinity Watch (2020)

Score: +1

Josh Brolin

as Thanos in Warlock and the Infinity Watch (2020)

Score: +1

Jeremy Allen White

as Magus in Warlock and the Infinity Watch (2020)

Score: +1