Suggestions by @showcast

Andrew Garfield

as Scott Pym in Marvel's Superverse

Score: +1

Dove Cameron

as Jane Foster in Marvel's Superverse

Score: +1

Jake T. Austin

as Bucky Barnes in Marvel's Superverse

Score: +1

Jordan Calloway

as Rhodey Rhodes in Marvel's Superverse

Score: +1

Aldis Hodge

as T'Challa in Marvel's Superverse

Score: +1

Madeline Brewer

as Natasha Romanova in Marvel's Superverse

Score: +1

Lili Reinhart

as Carol Denvers in Marvel's Superverse

Score: -1

Zoey Deutch

as Carol Denvers in Marvel's Superverse

Score: +1

Dakota Fanning

as Carol Denvers in Marvel's Superverse

Score: -1

Katherine McNamara

as Carol Denvers in Marvel's Superverse

Score: -1

Hayden Summerall

as Peter Parker in Marvel's Superverse

Score: +1

Noah Jupe

as Peter Parker in Marvel's Superverse

Score: -1

Dylan O'Brien

as Matt Murdock in Marvel's Superverse

Score: -1

David Henrie

as Matt Murdock in Marvel's Superverse

Score: +1

Colton Haynes

as Matt Murdock in Marvel's Superverse

Score: -1

Gus Kenworthy

as Matt Murdock in Marvel's Superverse

Score: -1