Suggestions by @shining_solo

Jenna Ortega

as Hannah Foster in Nightmare Time: Yellow Jacket

Dove Cameron

as Lex Foster in Nightmare Time: Yellow Jacket

Travis Barker

as Skud in Nightmare Time: Daddy/ Killer Track

Brendon Urie

as Thrash in Nightmare Time: Daddy/ Killer Track

Sean Astin

as Duke Keane in Nightmare Time: Daddy/ Killer Track

Alisha Boe

as Rose in Nightmare Time: Daddy/ Killer Track

Tanner Buchanan

as Kale in Nightmare Time: Daddy/ Killer Track

Alex Hirsch

as Barry Swift\ in Nightmare Time: Daddy/ Killer Track

Elizabeth Banks

as Sheila Young in Nightmare Time: Daddy/ Killer Track

Willem Dafoe

as Sherman Young in Nightmare Time: Daddy/ Killer Track

Nicole Kidman

as Miss Holloway in Nightmare Time: Daddy/ Killer Track

Dove Cameron

as Lex Foster in Nightmare Time: Daddy/ Killer Track

Jamie Foxx

as Frank Priceley in Nightmare Time: Daddy/ Killer Track

Kevin Michael Richardson

as Axeman in Nightmare Time: Perky's Buds/ Abstinence Camp

Izabela Vidovic

as Mary in Nightmare Time: Perky's Buds/ Abstinence Camp

Casey Simpson

as Noah in Nightmare Time: Perky's Buds/ Abstinence Camp

Bill Hader

as Boy Jerry in Nightmare Time: Perky's Buds/ Abstinence Camp

Ellie Kemper

as Girl Gerri in Nightmare Time: Perky's Buds/ Abstinence Camp

Ty Simpkins

as Gabe in Nightmare Time: Perky's Buds/ Abstinence Camp

Jordan Hare

as Grace Chastity in Nightmare Time: Perky's Buds/ Abstinence Camp