Suggestions by @shima

Richard Roxburgh

as Philippe De Chagny in Phantom of the Opera

Score: +1

Madeline Petsch

as Maddy in Euphoria (Season 3)

Score: 0

Luke Evans

as New actor introduction (3) in Euphoria (Season 3)

Score: +3

Chris McKay

as New actor introduction (3) in Euphoria (Season 3)

Score: -1

Madelaine Petsch

as Cassie in Euphoria (Season 3)

Score: +1

Willow Smith

as Gia Bennett in Euphoria (Season 3)

Score: +2

Lili Reinhart

as New actor introduction (1) in Euphoria (Season 3)

Score: +1

Dylan Sprouse

as Nate in Euphoria (Season 3)

Score: +1

Cole Sprouse

as Ash in Euphoria (Season 3)

Score: 0

Benedict Cumberbatch

as Joseph Buquet in Phantom of the Opera

Score: +1

Colm Wilkinson

as Monsieur Reyer in Phantom of the Opera

Score: +1

Jim Carrey

as Monsieur Reyer in Phantom of the Opera

Score: -1

Mädchen Amick

as Madame Giry in Phantom of the Opera

Score: +1

Tiera Skovbye

as Meg Giry in Phantom of the Opera

Score: +1

Ryan Gosling

as Viscount Raoul de Chagny in Phantom of the Opera

Score: +1

Anna Kendrick

as Christine Diaae in Phantom of the Opera

Score: +1

James Franco

as The Phantom in Phantom of the Opera

Score: 0

John Krasinski

as Beadle Bamford in Sweeny Todd The demon barber of Fleet Street (1997)

Score: 0

Fra Fee

as Adolfo Pirelli in Sweeny Todd The demon barber of Fleet Street (1997)

Score: 0

Noah Jupe

as Tobias 'Toby' Ragg in Sweeny Todd The demon barber of Fleet Street (1997)

Score: 0