Suggestions by @shawn_spencer

Michael Keaton

as Fatman in Fatman: The Dork Knight Begins

Score: +1

Shawn Spencer

as Jameson Nineteen in The Bunker Warlock

Score: +2

Eric Lavery

as Earth's Mightiest Nerd in The Bunker Warlock

Score: +2

Eric Lavery

as Earth's Mightiest Nerd in Kermit da Frog's Epic Guide to Surviving Life

Score: +2

Andrew Scott

as Constantine in The Bunker Warlock

Score: +1

Andrew Scott

as Constantine in Kermit da Frog's Epic Guide to Surviving Life

Score: +1

Bill Murray

as Dale Nineteen in The Bunker Warlock

Score: +2

James Roday Rodriguez

as Jameson Nineteen in The Bunker Warlock

Score: +2

Mike Myers

as Fatso Nineteen in The Bunker Warlock

Score: +1