Suggestions by @sfdogs

Chloë Grace Moretz

as Sophie Foster in Keeper of the Lost Cities

Score: -5

Sophie Grace

as Kristy Thomas in The Baby Sitters Club

Score: +11

Shay Rudolph

as Stacy McGill in The Baby Sitters Club

Score: +6

Maya Kendrick

as Kate Wetherall in The Mysterious Benedict Society

Score: -2

Sophie Knapp

as Amy Foster in Keeper of the Lost Cities

Score: +2

Dalya Knapp

as Amy Foster in Keeper of the Lost Cities

Score: +1

Dalya Knapp

as Marella Redek in Keeper of the Lost Cities

Score: -7

Laura Harrier

as Tiana in Disney Princesses

Score: +4

Sophie Knapp

as Biana Vacker in Keeper of the Lost Cities

Score: -8

Cobie Smulders

as Della Vacker in Keeper of the Lost Cities

Score: +4

Shay Rudolph

as Sophie Foster in Keeper of the Lost Cities

Score: +8

Shay Rudolph

as Kate Wetherall in The Mysterious Benedict Society

Score: 0

Angelina Jolie

as Pencilla in The Mysterious Benedict Society

Score: +1

Amandla Stenberg

as Rhonda Kazembe in The Mysterious Benedict Society

Score: -1

Cobie Smulders

as Miss Perumal in The Mysterious Benedict Society

Score: 0