Suggestions by @seryl

Ashley French

as Cossette in Les Miserables

Score: +1

Dina Spybey-Waters

as Elise Eliot-Atchison in The First Wives Club

Score: +1

Adria Tennor

as Annie MacDuggan in The First Wives Club

Score: +1

Gage Golightly

as Carol Cartman in A Carol Christmas

Score: +1

Cree Ivey

as Sydney White in Sydney White Remake

Score: +1

Jessica Amlee

as Júlia Lund in They

Score: +1

Katie Silverman

as Dr. Amelia Shepherd in Private Practice

Score: +1

Isabella Blake-Thomas

as Theodora in Oz the Great and Powerful

Score: 0

Keira Daniels

as Annabelle Bee Mullins in Annabelle Comes Home

Score: +1

Rachel McAdams

as Patsy Willets in Perfect Pie

Score: +1

Lauren Orlando

as Betty Cooper in Archie's Weird Mysteries

Score: 0

Kayla Madison

as Elena Gilbert in The Vampire Diaries 2019

Score: 0

Zac Efron

as Archie Andrews in Riverdale (2000s)

Score: +3

Taylor Swift

as Jennifer Gibson in Riverdale (2022-present)

Score: 0

Brooklynn Proulx

as Clare Abshire in The Time Traveler’s Wife

Score: 0

Auliʻi Cravalho

as Sonali Matthews in American Girl Dolls - Adult Fancasts

Score: -2

Mallory Margel

as Melissa Rochester in This Time Around

Score: +1

Emily Tennant

as Daphne Blake in Scooby Doo: Ghost Patrol

Score: +1

Vanessa Hudgens

as Pocahontas in Pocahontas (Live Action)

Score: -13