Suggestions by @sedalebandy

Hayden Panettiere

as Claire Bennet in Heroes Season 5

Score: +8

Jennifer Connelly

as Megan Reed in Deus Ex

Score: 0

Gary Oldman

as David Sarif in Deus Ex

Score: +1

Tom Ellis

as Adam Jenson in Deus Ex

Score: +3

Jim Caviezel

as Adam Jenson in Deus Ex

Score: +2