Suggestions by @sebastianconcha
5 suggestions
Micheal J Fox
as Peter Parker in Spider-Man (1982)
+0-1Score: -1
Steven Spielberg
as Director in Sam Raimi's Spider-Man Trilogy (1982-1987)
+2-1Score: +1
Elisabeth Shue
as Mary Jane Watson in Spider-Man (1982)
+4-3Score: +1
Elisabeth Shue
as Mary Jane Watson in Spider-Man 2 (1984)
+2-1Score: +1
Diane Lane
as Mary Jane Watson in Spider-Man 2 (1984)
+2-1Score: +1