Suggestions by @sarafelix

Dove Cameron

as Alice Liddell in Alice: Madness Returns (Live Action)

Score: +1

Drew Barrymore

as Helena in Better Than the Movies (Live Action)

Score: +2

Reese Witherspoon

as Helena in Better Than the Movies (Live Action)

Score: 0

Olivia Rodrigo

as Veronica Sawyer in Heathers (Reboot)

Score: +1

Kathryn Newton

as Veronica Sawyer in Heathers (Reboot)

Score: +1

Jenna Ortega

as Veronica Sawyer in Heathers (Reboot)

Score: +1

Benedict Cumberbatch

as Cheshire Cat in Alice: Madness Returns (Live Action)

Score: +1

Christian Bale

as Cheshire Cat in Alice: Madness Returns (Live Action)

Score: +1

Johnny Depp

as Cheshire Cat in Alice: Madness Returns (Live Action)

Score: +1

Willem Dafoe

as Mad Hatter in Alice: Madness Returns (Live Action)

Score: +1

Mackenzie Crook

as Mad Hatter in Alice: Madness Returns (Live Action)

Score: +1

Kristine Froseth

as Alice Liddell in Alice: Madness Returns (Live Action)

Score: +1

Hugh Jackman

as Angus Bumby in Alice: Madness Returns (Live Action)

Score: +1

Hugh Grant

as Angus Bumby in Alice: Madness Returns (Live Action)

Score: +1

Matthew McConaughey

as Angus Bumby in Alice: Madness Returns (Live Action)

Score: +2

Matthew Lillard

as Angus Bumby in Alice: Madness Returns (Live Action)

Score: +1

Mathew Lillard

as Angus Bumby in Alice: Madness Returns (Live Action)

Score: +1

Mathew Lilliard

as Angus Bumby in Alice: Madness Returns (Live Action)

Score: +1

Malina Weissman

as Alice Liddell in Alice: Madness Returns (Live Action)

Score: +1

Katherine Langford

as Alice Liddell in Alice: Madness Returns (Live Action)

Score: +2