Suggestions by @sapphicwolf

Everett McGill

as Virgil Cuts in Silver Bullet (2025?)

Score: +1

Steven Ogg

as Andy Fairton in Silver Bullet (2025?)

Score: +1

Andrew Lincoln

as Herb Kincaid in Silver Bullet (2025?)

Score: +1

Ty Burrell

as Bob Coslaw in Silver Bullet (2025?)

Score: +1

Cara Buono

as Nan Coslaw in Silver Bullet (2025?)

Score: +1

Megan Follows

as Older Jane in Silver Bullet (2025?)

Score: +1

Megan Follows

as Older Jane in Silver Bullet (2025?)

Score: +1

Amy Poehler

as Nan Coslaw in Silver Bullet (2025?)

Score: +1

Paul Rudd

as Andy Fairton in Silver Bullet (2025?)

Score: +1

Danny McBride

as Milt Sturmfuller in Silver Bullet (2025?)

Score: +1

Julia Butters

as Tammy Sturmfuller in Silver Bullet (2025?)

Score: +1

Lee Pace

as Reverend Lowe in Silver Bullet (2025?)

Score: +1

Gary Busey

as Arnie Westrum in Silver Bullet (2025?)

Score: +1

Tina Fey

as Older Jane in Silver Bullet (2025?)

Score: +1

Oscar Isaac

as Herb Kincaid in Silver Bullet (2025?)

Score: +1

Shannon Purser

as Stella Randolph in Silver Bullet (2025?)

Score: +1

Jack Dylan Grazer

as Brady Kincaid in Silver Bullet (2025?)

Score: +1

Ross Marquand

as Sheriff Joe Haller in Silver Bullet (2025?)

Score: +1

Luke Hemsworth

as Uncle Red in Silver Bullet (2025?)

Score: +2

Mckenna Grace

as Jane Coslaw in Silver Bullet (2025?)

Score: +2