Suggestions by @ryanb

Jack Black

as King Bowser in Super Mario RPG (Anime)

Score: +1

Anya Taylor-Joy

as Princess Toadstool in Super Mario RPG (Anime)

Score: +1

Charlie Day

as Luigi in Super Mario RPG (Anime)

Score: +1

Chris Pratt

as Mario in Super Mario RPG (Anime)

Score: +1

Alejandra Reynoso

as Moogle Girl in Final Fantasy VII: Advent Children (Movie English ReDub)

Score: +2

David Corenswet

as Kadaj in Final Fantasy VII: Advent Children (Movie English ReDub)

Score: 0

Paul Eiding

as Professor Hojo in Last Order: Final Fantasy VII (Anime English Dub)

Score: +1

Kyle Hebert

as Turk (Martial Artist) in Last Order: Final Fantasy VII (Anime English Dub)

Score: +1

Michelle Ruff

as Turk (Shotgun) in Last Order: Final Fantasy VII (Anime English Dub)

Score: +1

Doug Erholtz

as Turk (Two Guns) in Last Order: Final Fantasy VII (Anime English Dub)

Score: +1

Johnny Yong Bosch

as Turk (Rod) in Last Order: Final Fantasy VII (Anime English Dub)

Score: +1

Bettina Bush

as Elena in Last Order: Final Fantasy VII (Anime English Dub)

Score: +1

Crispin Freeman

as Rude in Last Order: Final Fantasy VII (Anime English Dub)

Score: +1

Quinton Flynn

as Reno in Last Order: Final Fantasy VII (Anime English Dub)

Score: +1

Ryun Yu

as Tseng in Last Order: Final Fantasy VII (Anime English Dub)

Score: +1

George Newbern

as Sephiroth in Last Order: Final Fantasy VII (Anime English Dub)

Score: +1

Rachel Leigh Cook

as Tifa Lockhart in Last Order: Final Fantasy VII (Anime English Dub)

Score: +1

Steve Burton

as Cloud Strife in Last Order: Final Fantasy VII (Anime English Dub)

Score: +1

Rick Gomez

as Zack Fair in Last Order: Final Fantasy VII (Anime English Dub)

Score: +1

Josh Gilman

as Angeal Hewley in Final Fantasy VII: Ever Crisis (Video Game English Dub)

Score: 0